The History of Rome, Volume IV: The Revolution by Theodor Mommsen

The History of Rome, Volume IV: The Revolution by Theodor Mommsen is a seminal work in historical scholarship, originally written in German and translated into English by William Purdie Dickson. Mommsen, a renowned historian and Nobel laureate, presents a detailed account of Rome’s political and military developments during the period of revolution leading to the fall of the Roman Republic. The volume focuses on significant events from the time of the Gracchi brothers through the rise of Sulla and the early days of the Roman Empire.

The book explores the internal upheavals in Rome, notably the struggles between reformers like the Gracchi and conservatives. It also touches on the military campaigns and governance that shaped the Roman world. The author’s comprehensive narrative provides an in-depth analysis of how revolutionary forces, political betrayal, and military ambition changed the course of Roman history.

The central thesis of the book is to examine the internal conflicts within Rome, focusing on the shifting power dynamics, political reforms, and military reforms, and how these contributed to the ultimate downfall of the Republic. Mommsen’s narrative places significant emphasis on the socio-political changes that triggered the breakdown of traditional Roman structures.

Summary

In this volume, Mommsen elaborates on several key figures and events that define the revolution in Rome. Here is a summary of the book’s major themes and historical events:

• The Gracchi Brothers and Reform Movements:
  The Gracchi brothers, Tiberius and Gaius, attempted significant land reforms to address economic inequality. They pushed for redistributing land to the poor, but their efforts faced staunch opposition from the aristocracy, which ultimately led to Tiberius’s violent death and Gaius’s tragic demise. These reforms marked the beginning of the larger conflict between the populares and optimates.
• The Revolution of Gaius Gracchus:
  Gaius’s reforms were even more radical, advocating for economic, political, and judicial changes. His attempt to challenge the Senate and redistribute wealth brought him into conflict with the elite, resulting in a violent end to his movement. This event serves as a precursor to the later populist revolutions in Rome.
• The Role of Marius and Sulla:
  Gaius Marius’s military reforms played a pivotal role in the evolution of Roman politics, shifting power from the Senate to the army. Sulla’s march on Rome and his subsequent dictatorship marked a violent turning point in the republic’s governance, initiating a period of civil wars.
• Social and Economic Struggles:
  The book discusses the widening gap between the wealthy elite and the impoverished masses, exacerbated by warfare and political instability. These struggles set the stage for the larger revolution that would lead to the end of the Republic.
• The Decline of the Senate:
  The traditional power structures, particularly the Senate, were increasingly undermined by populist movements, military generals, and the growing power of the plebeian class.

Chronological Events in The History of Rome, Vol. 4: The Revolution:

1. 133 BCE – Tiberius Gracchus becomes Tribune of the Plebs

• Tiberius Gracchus proposes land reforms to redistribute public land to the poor. His reforms meet strong opposition from the Senate, leading to political conflict and his eventual murder.

1. 123 BCE – Gaius Gracchus becomes Tribune of the Plebs

• Gaius, brother of Tiberius, continues the reform movement by proposing more radical social and political changes. He attempts to extend the reforms of his brother, including grain subsidies and Roman citizenship for all Italians. Gaius meets similar resistance, and like his brother, he is killed in a violent political clash.

1. 107 BCE – Marius’ Military Reforms

• Gaius Marius, a key figure in the military revolution, reforms the Roman army by allowing the capite censi (landless citizens) to enlist, creating a professional army that is loyal to its general rather than the state. This shift in allegiance significantly impacts Roman politics.

1. 91-88 BCE – Social War (War with Italian Allies)

• The Italian allies (socii) revolt against Rome due to inequality and the denial of Roman citizenship. The war ends with Rome granting citizenship to most of the Italian allies, altering the political structure of Rome.

1. 88 BCE – Sulla’s First March on Rome

• Lucius Cornelius Sulla marches on Rome, overthrowing the government in order to secure his command against Mithridates. This marks the first time a Roman general uses his army to seize control of the city, setting a precedent for future military dictatorships.

1. 87 BCE – Sulla’s Dictatorship and Reforms

• After Sulla’s return from the East, he enacts reforms to restore the Senate’s power and to eliminate his political enemies. His actions mark the beginning of a shift from the Republic to more autocratic rule.

1. 82-79 BCE – Sulla’s Dictatorship

• Sulla’s reforms lay the groundwork for the eventual rise of autocratic rule in Rome. He steps down as dictator in 79 BCE but leaves behind a legacy of military and political turmoil that sets the stage for future civil wars.

1. 73-71 BCE – Slave Rebellion under Spartacus

• Spartacus, a gladiator, leads a major slave revolt against Rome. While initially successful, the rebellion is crushed, but it underscores the growing unrest in the Roman world, especially among the lower classes.

1. 60 BCE – Formation of the First Triumvirate

• Julius Caesar, Pompey, and Crassus form the First Triumvirate, a political alliance that seeks to dominate Roman politics and bypass the Senate. This coalition marks the breakdown of traditional Republican politics.

1. 49 BCE – Caesar Crosses the Rubicon
   • Julius Caesar crosses the Rubicon River with his army, defying the Senate and starting a civil war. His famous phrase, “The die is cast,” marks the point of no return in the conflict between him and Pompey.
2. 48 BCE – Battle of Pharsalus
   • Julius Caesar defeats Pompey in the Battle of Pharsalus, leading to Pompey’s flight to Egypt and subsequent murder. Caesar becomes the undisputed ruler of Rome.
3. 44 BCE – Assassination of Julius Caesar
   • Julius Caesar is assassinated by a group of senators led by Brutus and Cassius. His death plunges Rome into further chaos, leading to the rise of the Second Triumvirate (Octavian, Mark Antony, and Lepidus).
4. 42 BCE – Battle of Philippi
   • The Second Triumvirate defeats the forces of Brutus and Cassius at the Battle of Philippi. This battle solidifies the power of Octavian and Mark Antony.
5. 31 BCE – Battle of Actium
   • Octavian defeats Mark Antony and Cleopatra at the Battle of Actium. This marks the end of the civil wars and the beginning of Octavian’s reign as the first Roman emperor (Augustus).

This overview covers the main political and military milestones that Mommsen discusses in the context of the Roman Revolution. Each of these events plays a crucial role in the political transformations that ultimately led to the collapse of the Roman Republic and the rise of the Roman Empire.

If you need further elaboration on any specific event or section, feel free to ask!

Evidence Snapshot

Mommsen’s historical narrative draws on a wealth of primary sources, including Roman legal texts, military reports, and speeches from the era. He incorporates the works of contemporary historians and scholars to support his arguments.

His writing also includes direct references to Roman political figures like Marius, Sulla, and the Gracchi brothers, whose actions had lasting consequences for Rome’s future. Additionally, Mommsen’s examination of Roman law, culture, and the military underpins his argument that the revolution was not just a political or military event, but a societal transformation.

Best For / Not For

This book is ideal for readers with an interest in classical history, particularly Roman history, political theory, and military history. Scholars and students studying the transition from the Roman Republic to the Empire will find this work indispensable. Those with an academic interest in the evolution of political systems and revolutions will benefit from Mommsen’s thorough analysis.

Casual readers or those looking for an easy, introductory read might find this book challenging. It is deeply analytical and assumes a certain level of prior knowledge of Roman history. Those unfamiliar with ancient Roman political structures or historical events might find the work overwhelming.

5. Conclusion

Mommsen’s The History of Rome, Vol. 4 offers a profound analysis of the political, social, and military events that led to the downfall of the Roman Republic. His meticulous research and detailed narrative provide invaluable insights into the complexities of Roman history. However, the book’s dense and scholarly approach may deter general readers.

This book is highly recommended for advanced students of history, particularly those interested in Roman political systems, military reforms, and the societal changes that led to the rise of the Roman Empire. It is less suitable for those seeking a straightforward historical narrative but is essential for anyone studying the era in depth.

---

The History of Rome, Vol. 1
The History of Rome, Vol. 2
The History of Rome, Vol. 3